LaToya Cantrell recall, New Orleans, Louisiana (2022-2023)
LaToya Cantrell was first elected mayor of New Orleans in November 2017, becoming the first female mayor in the city’s history. She had previously served on the New Orleans City Council. Cantrell won re-election in November 2021, easily defeating opponents with nearly 65% of the vote. Her current term runs through 2025.
Recall Effort Initiated in August 2022
In August 2022, a group of New Orleans residents launched a recall effort seeking to remove Mayor Cantrell from office early. The petition was led by locals Eileen Carter and Belden Batiste. They accused Cantrell of failing to make New Orleans a priority and properly execute her mayoral responsibilities.
Reasons and Critics Behind Recall Campaign
Those pushing for Cantrell’s recall cited numerous grievances. These included rising crime rates, crumbling infrastructure, unaffordable housing, and a lack of communication between the mayor and city departments. Critics said Cantrell was not prioritizing key issues like the murder rate, blight removal, and storm recovery. Some accused her of retaliation and cronyism.
Requirements and Changes to Signature Threshold
Initial Signature Requirement Over 50,000
To force a special recall election in New Orleans, organizers needed to collect valid signatures equal to 20% of registered voters in the city. Based on voter rolls at the time, this meant obtaining over 53,000 verified signatures within a 180-day window.
Threshold Lowered Twice Due to Voter Roll Drop
The signature requirement was first adjusted down to 49,975 in late 2022 after a recalculation of registered voters in New Orleans. Recall organizers later sued to have the threshold reduced further, arguing over 30,000 inactive voters should be removed from the rolls.
Recall Organizers Sue to Further Reduce Threshold
In early 2023, Secretary of State Kyle Ardoin agreed to a consent judgment that cut the signature requirement to 44,975 registered voters. This reflected the organizer’s claim that New Orleans had 30,000 fewer eligible voters than stated. Mayor Cantrell vowed to fight the retroactive change.
Signature Collection and Verification Process
49,000+ Signatures Submitted in February
In late February, recall organizers submitted over 49,000 collected signatures, believing this surpassed even the original higher threshold. The registrar now had to verify the petitions.
Only 27,243 Signatures Verified as Valid
After reviewing the submitted signatures, the New Orleans registrar of voters certified only 27,243 as valid. Nearly 7,500 signatures were rejected for various reasons. This final verified total fell short of the requirement.
Falls Short of Requirement Despite Threshold Drop
So even with the reduced signature threshold they had sued for, recall proponents did not collect and verify enough to force a special election. The significant signature invalid rate had doomed their efforts.
Legal Challenges Filed by Mayor Cantrell
Lawsuit Questions Authority to Change Threshold
After the failed petition, Mayor Cantrell went on the offensive legally. She sued to challenge the registrar’s authority to retroactively alter the signature requirement per the consent judgment.
Petition Filed to Reverse Agreement on Lower Threshold
Cantrell also petitioned the court to reverse the Secretary of State’s agreement to lower the threshold based on inactive voters. Her lawsuits disputed changing rules mid-process.
What This Means Moving Forward
Cantrell Avoids Special Recall Election
The unsuccessful signature drive ensures Mayor Cantrell will avoid a special recall election before her term ends. Without a court-ordered remedy, she will remain in office through the 2025 election.
Term Runs Through 2025 as Scheduled
Despite the recall attempt, Cantrell will continue serving as New Orleans mayor for the remainder of her four-year term. She was re-elected in November 2021 and inaugurated in May 2022.
Continued Debates Over Crime and Leadership
However, the issues that drove the recall, like crime and infrastructure, will persist as hot topics. Cantrell will face ongoing pressure to address these concerns and criticism over her leadership.
The recall effort against Mayor LaToya Cantrell gained substantial steam and attention. But ultimately a lack of verified signatures doomed the push before any recall vote. While avoiding a special election, Cantrell still faces discontent in New Orleans towards rising crime, blight, and her administration’s direction. However, her term now continues uninterrupted until the next New Orleans mayoral election in 2025. She will need to balance reacting to recall criticisms and effectively leading the city through complex challenges in the remainder of her term.
How many signatures were required to recall the mayor?
The original requirement was over 53,000 based on registered voters. It was lowered twice, eventually to 44,975 due to dropped voters.
How many valid signatures did recall organizers submit?
In the end, the New Orleans registrar verified only 27,243 valid signatures out of over 49,000 submitted.
What were the main reasons people wanted to recall Mayor Cantrell?
Critics cited issues like high crime, crumbling infrastructure, lack of affordable housing, and poor communication by the mayor.
What happens next for Mayor Cantrell?
With the recall failing, Cantrell will remain mayor through her current term that ends in January 2026 without a special election.
When is the next regular mayoral election in New Orleans?
The next open New Orleans mayoral election will be in Fall 2025 for the term starting in 2026. Cantrell could run again.